Most Were Silent

Most Were Silent

Hardcover English 144 pages 17 × 24 cm Print run 500

Description

In Most Were Silent, Anush Hamzehian and Vittorio Mortarotti work outward from Alamogordo, New Mexico, near the site of the first atomic bomb test. The photographers spent more than a month in the area in 2016. Their pictures ask how a place can carry the memory of an event that residents and visitors did not all experience in the same way. A photograph of a white cloud rising behind a fence holds the eye because it gives so little away about what produced it. The photograph’s uncertainty matters in a book whose subject is the distance between an event and the ways it is remembered.

Many of the pictures occupy the left page on their own. Cactus pads, a face with closed eyes, and a flock above a tree line appear in black and white, each with an empty page opposite. The blank page leaves time to consider a picture before another one arrives. A diffuse amber image on the right interrupts that rhythm and gives the reader something with few recognizable features to grasp. The alternation brings attention to the conditions of looking, as well as to what was there in front of the camera.

An English-language spread gives over its left page to a first-person account of combat. The speaker remembers friends who died and the plans they had made for when they got home. The plainness of this recollection changes how the more elusive photographs can be read. The diagonal cable on a wall and the speaker’s account give the reader two distinct kinds of detail to carry from one page to another.

The 2018 Skinnerboox hardcover, designed by Hans Gremmen, was issued in 500 copies with a four-page booklet. It completes the sequence of books begun with The First Day of Good Weather and Eden. For a collector of the trilogy or of Gremmen’s books, this volume makes a good study in how repeated placement, an occasional reversal, and the interruption of a written voice can shape an account of historical memory.

Preview Pages

Videos

Oppenheimer remembers Trinity (historical source of the book’s title)
Oppenheimer remembers Trinity (historical source of the book’s title)

Reviews & Articles

Most Were Silent

The gallery’s account of its 2018 Turin exhibition follows Hamzehian and Mortarotti from a month of work around Alamogordo to an installation about war and memory. One video showed a student reading a Braille transcription of an eyewitness account of Trinity. Elsewhere a filmed recollection from a survivor of the Iraq war appeared with black-and-white photographs of faces and places. A final film gathered perspectives from visitors at the Trinity Site. The gallery explains how the exhibition’s title came from Oppenheimer’s recollection of the different ways people reacted to the first test. Read Article

Our 2018 and highlights for a year to come

In a review of its 2018 publications, Skinnerboox places Most Were Silent among its collaborations with photobook designers. The publisher introduces Hans Gremmen’s work on the third volume by Vittorio Mortarotti and Anush Hamzehian and identifies a specific choice that structures the book: most pictures appear on the left-hand page. The publisher describes the resulting pause as a way to bring together the photographs’ attention to landscape and the project’s concern with war and memory. The entry includes a photograph from the series and records that the work had already been shown in Turin and Bologna. Read Article

Anush Hamzehian e Vittorio Mortarotti: Most Were Silent

Spazio Labo describes Most Were Silent as an inquiry into the way a shared history changes when seen through individual memory. Its account locates the artists’ 2016 fieldwork around Alamogordo, near the site of the 1945 Trinity test. It explains why the Bologna presentation put still photographs in conversation with archival footage, objects and short documentaries, allowing the links among them to remain indirect. The centre relates this approach to the duo’s earlier work on tsunami survivors, former miners and border communities. It also gives details of the October 2018 book presentation with the artists and publisher Milo Montelli. Read Article

Award history

  • 2018

    LUMA Rencontres Dummy Book Award

    Other award · Shortlisted

    The Rencontres d’Arles shortlisted the prepublication dummy. The linked edition is the subsequently published first trade hardcover.

COMMUNITY DISCUSSION

Discuss this entry

Share interpretations, reading notes, and source-aware questions. For catalog corrections, use the feedback form below.

My discussions

No discussion yet. Start the first focused conversation.

Sign in to join the discussion.